Silicon Labs
|
Silicon Labs Community Silicon Labs Community
  • Products
    1. 8-bit MCU
    2. 32-bit MCU
    3. Bluetooth
    4. Proprietary
    5. Wi-Fi
    6. Zigbee & Thread
    7. Z-Wave
    8. Interface
    9. Isolation
    10. Power
    11. Sensors
    12. Timing
  • Development Tools
    1. Simplicity Studio
    2. Third Party Tools
  • Expert's Corner
    1. Announcements
    2. Blog
    3. General Interest
    4. Projects
How to Buy
English
  • English
  • 简体中文
  • 日本語
//
Community // Blog

Tech Talks Blog: Wireless Modules vs. Wireless SoCs

05/142/2020 | 09:45 PM
Tracy Boyd
Employee

Level 4


At first glance, a system-on-a-chip (SoC) might seem like the most cost-efficient option for your wireless design. However, the hidden design costs of using an SoC could mean that a wireless module is the better choice. In this Tech Talks session, product marketing manager, Joe Tillison, outlines the criteria for making the best choices for your design. Click here to watch the entire session and register now for future Tech Talks. Here are some of the key takeaways from Joe's presentation.

Start with a Break-Even Analysis

Today's highly integrated SoCs provide the lowest possible bill of materials (BoM) cost option. However, SoCs are more challenging to design with and thus require research and development (R&D) budget, specialized measurement equipment, and staff expertise in RF design and compliance testing. While modules are more expensive, they are easier to use and come pre-certified for RF compliance agencies, enabling faster time to market. So, how do you decide which option to use? Joe recommends starting with a break-even analysis.

The following break-even analysis table shows that, at lower volumes, the SoC profit is negative due to the upfront costs of using an SoC in your design.

The annual break-even volume between SoCs and modules in this example is around 300,000 units. Although the break-even point may seem surprisingly high, there is a simple reason: as chip pricing has come down, so has the gap between chip pricing and module pricing. At high volumes, there can be as little as $1 price difference between chips and modules.

SoC and Module Price Comparisons Ignore Other Hidden Costs

If you're only comparing chip pricing to module pricing, you're ignoring some hidden costs. Development with SoCs requires RF engineers with specialized skills, which adds to overhead development cost. Additionally, SoCs must undergo compliance testing and require the use of specialized lab equipment and facilities. Any issues discovered during compliance testing can be costly to fix in terms of redesign and lab expenses, all of which can cause time to market delays.

Wireless modules eliminate many of the risks associated with SoCs. They are easy to use in designs and involve only a few simple guidelines. Additionally, modules are fully tested and characterized by the vendor. End products using pre-certified modules inherit the module's certifications. Overall, modules provide a faster path to revenue.

Decision-Making Criteria

When choosing between an SoC or a module for your wireless design, consider the following important factors:

  • Volume versus cost – what is your break-even point?
  • Availability of resources – RF expertise, software and lab equipment
  • Time to market costs – SoCs require longer development times
  • Risk tolerance – lost time to market and market share if the project is delayed

Silicon Labs offers the best of both worlds. Our module and SoC families use the same tools and software, so the developer experience is the same no matter which option you choose. Our pre-certified modules, which have already been tested to meet alliance standards and RF regulatory requirements, ensure certification of your end products. Silicon Labs’ reference designs, technical documentation and support teams assist experienced RF engineers in efficiently designing with our SoCs and enable developers with little to no RF experience to add wireless connectivity to their IoT products using modules.

When it comes to adding wireless functionality to your products, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Let us help you find the best choice for your wireless development needs. To learn more about our wireless module and SoC solutions, contact your Silicon Labs sales representative.

  • Blog Posts

Tags

  • Wireless
  • High Performance Jitter Attenuators
  • EFR32FG22 Series 2 SoCs
  • EFR32MG21 Series 2 SoCs
  • Security
  • Bluegiga Legacy Modules
  • Zigbee SDK
  • ZigBee and Thread
  • EFR32BG13 Series 1 Modules
  • Internet Infrastructure
  • Sensors
  • Wireless Xpress BGX13
  • Blue Gecko Bluetooth Low Energy SoCs
  • Z-Wave
  • Micrium OS
  • Blog Posts
  • Low Jitter Clock Generators
  • Bluetooth Classic
  • Makers
  • Flex SDK
  • Tips and Tricks
  • timing
  • Smart Cities
  • Smart Homes
  • IoT Heroes
  • Reviews
  • RAIL
  • Simplicity Studio
  • Tiny Gecko
  • EFR32MG22 Series 2 SoCs
  • Mighty Gecko SoCs
  • Timing
  • Temperature Sensors
  • Blue Gecko Bluetooth Low Energy Modules
  • Ultra Low Jitter Clock Generators
  • General Purpose Clock Generators
  • EFR32BG22 Series 2 SoCs
  • Industry 4.0
  • Giant Gecko
  • 32-bit MCUs
  • Bluetooth Low Energy
  • 32-bit MCU SDK
  • Gecko
  • Microcontrollers
  • Jitter Attenuators
  • EFR32BG21 Series 2 SoCs
  • News and Events
  • Wi-Fi
  • Bluetooth SDK
  • Community Spotlight
  • Clock Generators
  • Biometric Sensors
  • General Purpose Jitter Attenuators
  • Giant Gecko S1
  • WF200
  • Flex Gecko
  • Internet of Things
  • 8-bit MCUs
  • Wireless Jitter Attenuators
  • Isolation
  • Powered Devices
  • Power

Top Authors

  • Avatar image Siliconlabs
  • Avatar image Jackie Padgett
  • Avatar image Nari Shin
  • Avatar image lynchtron
  • Avatar image deirdrewalsh
  • Avatar image Lance Looper
  • Avatar image lethawicker

Archives

  • 2016 March
  • 2016 April
  • 2016 May
  • 2016 June
  • 2016 July
  • 2016 August
  • 2016 September
  • 2016 October
  • 2016 November
  • 2016 December
  • 2017 January
  • 2017 February
  • 2017 March
  • 2017 April
  • 2017 May
  • 2017 June
  • 2017 July
  • 2017 August
  • 2017 September
  • 2017 October
  • 2017 November
  • 2017 December
  • 2018 January
  • 2018 February
  • 2018 March
  • 2018 April
  • 2018 May
  • 2018 June
  • 2018 July
  • 2018 August
  • 2018 September
  • 2018 October
  • 2018 November
  • 2018 December
  • 2019 January
  • 2019 February
  • 2019 March
  • 2019 April
  • 2019 May
  • 2019 June
  • 2019 July
  • 2019 August
  • 2019 September
  • 2019 October
  • 2019 November
  • 2019 December
  • 2020 January
  • 2020 February
  • 2020 March
  • 2020 April
  • 2020 May
  • 2020 June
  • 2020 July
  • 2020 August
  • 2020 September
  • 2020 October
  • 2020 November
  • 2020 December
  • 2021 January
  • 2021 February
Silicon Labs
Stay Connected With Us
Plug into the latest on Silicon Labs products, including product releases and resources, documentation updates, PCN notifications, upcoming events, and more.
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Community
  • Contact Us
  • Corporate Responsibility
  • Privacy and Terms
  • Press Room
  • Investor Relations
  • Site Feedback
  • Cookies
Copyright © Silicon Laboratories. All rights reserved.
粤ICP备15107361号
Also of Interest:
  • Bring Your IoT Designs to Life with Smart,...
  • A Guide to IoT Protocols at Works With...
  • IoT Hero Rainus Enhances the In-Store Shopping...