TECH TALK

Why Sub-GHz?

This Tech Talk explores the advantages of using license-free Sub-GHz frequency bands, and why Sub-GHz is chosen over other wireless connectivity options.

About This Tech Talk

There has been a resurgence of sub-GHz connectivity with the emergence of standards like Wi-SUN, Amazon Sidewalk, and Z-Wave. We will explore some of the advantages of using the license-free sub-GHz frequency bands, the challenges to developing Sub-GHz devices, and some reasons why you choose a Sub-GHz standard over other connectivity options.

You can view the accompanying slides and recorded session below.

Speaker

Chad Steider

Chad Steider

Senior Product Marketing Manager
Silicon Labs

Duration

30 Minute Presentation

15 Minute Q&A



Transcript

Hello, everyone. Good morning and good afternoon. Welcome to this week's LPWAN Tech Talk, where we will talk about why Sub-GHz. This is an important topic for us because, with different frequency bands and so many wireless protocols, it's a question we get often from our audience and customers when they're building their applications. Which protocol is right for me? Should I go 2.4 gig, or should I look into sub-GHz? We realize that dilemma because there are different design considerations depending on your use cases. There are pros and cons with 2.4 and sub-GHz, and that's why we have this session where we will answer all these questions and more. And with that, I am Ashish Tega. I'm a product marketing manager at Silicon Labs, primarily focused on our hardware and software launches for Bluetooth, and I'm your host for today's session. And I'm joined today by Chad Steiger, who will be presenting this tech talk. I'm sure most of you know Chad. He's a senior product marketing manager here at Silicon Labs. His team is focused on launches for sub-GHz, LPWAN, and MCU. Chad has been in the semiconductor industry for over 16 years. He has a wealth of experience when it comes to low-power wireless technologies and devices. So before I hand it off to Chad, as always, if you have any questions, please use the Q&A chat box on the Zoom. We will try and answer as many questions as we can. We have Jacob Johnson, our field application engineer, and Matt Maupin, our 15.4 marketing manager, helping us with the Q&A at the back end. So please don't wait till the end of the session to ask your questions. Chad, with that, please take it away. Yeah, thanks, Ashish. Hello, and welcome everybody. I'm really excited to bring this topic to you guys today. As the product marketing manager for these technologies, it gives me a unique perspective into how they're impacting IoT. And I think with all the press and all the momentum that 2.4 gig standards like Matter and we're seeing the emergence of low-power Wi-Fi, I think it's important to talk through the part that sub-GHz networks are going to continue to play in the IoT, both, kind of in the immediate future and the long-term future. So we're going to start with an overview of sub-GHz RF in general and make sure we're all starting from the same point. When I talk about sub-GHz RF, I'm talking about frequencies obviously less than one gigahertz, and these frequencies are broken up into different ISM bands, and different frequency bands are supported in different parts of the world. So Europe is really 433 megahertz and 868. US and Latin America is 315 and 915, and Japan, 426 and 920. And then India, which is one of the bigger emerging markets for these technologies, is really just that 868 band. Most of the devices we're going to talk about today are going to use the unlicensed spectrum, and these ISM bands are broken up into licensed and unlicensed portions. The licensed portions are typically used by things like cellular, where the carriers are buying a portion of the spectrum and then have free will to use that spectrum as they see fit within the regulations. And this has both advantages and disadvantages. When you take this licensed approach, you are very limited into the spectrum that you have available. So as you look at standing up new technologies, you have to find places in your spectrum to make those fit. So that's why we see sunsetting of older cellular technologies where, with the unlicensed spectrum, you don't really have those same kind of restraints that you do in those license bands. Sub-GHz networks are typically associated with long-range, low-power applications. And the adoption of these has really been a pretty broad set of use cases, but in this context, it's really been driven by things like broad entrepreneurs, infrastructure, and security. Recently, we've seen an emergence of different standards in the sub-GHz space. So things like Wi-SUN, Wirepas, and Amazon Sidewalk are those emerging technologies that we're seeing, where things like LoRaWAN and Z-Wave have been around for a longer time, and we know the value propositions of those technologies. So going into the advantages of sub-GHz, we're really talking about longer point-to-point transmission range than 2.4 or five gig, and that's driven by the physics. These longer wavelengths can easily bypass obstacles and penetrate buildings. They're less prone to reflections, lowering free space path loss. So when you look at this graphic here on the left part of the slide, when you look at this obstacle-affected range of the 2.4 gig standards like Bluetooth and Wi-Fi, you're really talking about ranges less than 100 meters. When you put a sub-GHz network in the same condition, you're still getting ranges of a kilometer plus, depending on the frequency and the modulation and everything that you choose to use, but that's a pretty good baseline. There's less congestion in the sub-GHz spectrum than there is in the 2.4 gig spectrum, especially around the home and in warehouses and in some of these applications that are emerging for IoT. The adoption of Bluetooth and Matter and Wi-Fi have really started crowding that 2.4 gig spectrum, which is why we're seeing Wi-Fi move into five gig and six gig, to really find that free space while increasing data rates. Sub-GHz devices typically have lower transmission duty cycles, which also helps free space up in the spectrum. You're limited to how long you can transmit so that you can make space for other devices that want to use that same unlicensed spectrum. Sub-GHz does have some power efficiency advantages over the 2.4 gig network. The lower data rates and better range performance lower the overall system power burden. When you're talking about getting ranges of that 100-meter range through obstacles with the 2.4 gig standard, you typically have to have a pretty high output power. You can greatly scale back the output power of sub-GHz devices depending on the range you need and depending on your environment and save a lot of power, since we know those transmit periods are typically the greatest power consumer in the life of your product. And then the less congestion in the spectrum also leads to fewer retries. So if I only have to transmit once to get a message through versus three or four times, I'm obviously saving a pretty significant amount of power in that instance. Cost-effectiveness. Proprietary networks, and sub-GHz specifically, can really be optimized for single applications, and that's really how they've been used in the past. You look at things like key fobs. Key fobs have historically been sub-GHz based. It's a really simple system with either an 8-bit MCU and a transceiver or, in some cases, just a small 8-bit wireless SoC. And those solutions are very inexpensive because you don't have to carry the overhead of those 2.4 gig standards like Bluetooth or Wi-Fi. So you can really optimize for your application if you choose to. And then from a security and reliability standpoint, because these networks have historically been proprietary, you can keep the characteristics of your network really private, and increase the security that way. Also, the tools needed to potentially compromise these sub-GHz networks are not as readily available as they are for the 2.4 gig counterparts. Now, we are seeing the emergence of standards-based solutions We're seeing a drive to more enterprise-level security with certificates and public-private pair encryption that are aiming to keep that same level of security that folks are used to with sub-GHz, while also creating an interoperable environment for people to use. Now, that's not to say there aren't disadvantages with sub-GHz. Historically, they've really been limited to lower data rates, so the narrower bandwidth and the fewer number of channels really restrict the amount of data that can be sent within your transmit windows. We are seeing that change a little bit with the introduction of OFDM to the 802.15.4g spec that Wi-SUN is built off of. Now you can get data rates up to about 2.4 megabits per second, or to follow the Wi-SUN standard, or 3.6, if you just look at 15.4g. So there are some things happening to address the lower data rate. But still, when you look at things like Wi-Fi and we're talking about megabits or gigabits per second, which is much higher than what you see from sub-GHz, which are typically in the hundreds of kilobits range. There are some challenges if you want to deploy a product worldwide. I mentioned in the first slide the different frequencies for different parts of the world. So, if you have a product that you want to deploy in the US and Europe, you may have to do two discrete RF designs, where with 2.4 gig, that's a worldwide standard or a worldwide supported frequency, so you don't need to worry about that. And then also, certain geographies limit the output power or duty cycle. We've seen this with Z-Wave long range in certain parts of the world. We also see it in India with our smart metering deployments where you're really limited to 865 to 868 megahertz. So you're very limited on the number of channels and very limited on the bandwidth that you have available that affect the operation of these devices in these other regions. There's also some space consideration. Again, going back to the physics, the longer wavelengths do require larger antennas. So if you have an extremely space-constrained application, you may run into some issues on how do I fit my antenna in this really small package. And then multipath fading is a real problem for sub-GHz. We've seen it in some testing we've done in often with our Wi-SUN solutions. Simple modulations like FSK really do get degraded in those urban environments, which is one of the reasons why standards like Wi-SUN are looking at expanding to include OFDM, which doesn't have that same vulnerability. And then while it was a plus for security, it's also a little bit of a disadvantage for interoperability. The fact that these networks have historically been proprietary. If you look at smart city implementations, for example, you may have meters on one network and streetlights on another, and sensors on a third. So by keeping these networks private, and application specific, it does create some challenges as we look to scale sub-GHz deployment. And I've talked a lot about the use cases in smart city and the use cases in some of these larger applications, but sub-GHz has a major place in the home in extending IoT beyond the front door. I listened to our CTO, Daniel Cooley, speak a week or so ago, and the market is moving with the assumption that we're moving past the early adopter phase for IoT. We've finally crossed that hurdle, and now we're moving on to the next phase. And as we do that, those early adopters are now looking for use cases for IoT outside the home. How can I add intelligence to improve resource utilization, increase security, or even elevate the homeowner experience? And one of the easiest ways to do that is with sub-GHz. I know I've got a bunch of smart lights in my home, and when I look outside, my lights are controlled with just a simple dusk-to-dawn setting. So, how can I increase my user experience with those exterior lights? And you have some challenges with 2.4 gig. If you have hubs or something in your house, they may not be able to reach outside, even with the mesh capability of standards like Matter. So the easiest way to do it is just you can look at something like Z-Wave or Z-Wave Long Range and drop those devices in and really eliminate those range concerns. Sub-GHz already has a major foothold within homes. If you have a garage door opener in your house that was installed before 2022 is probably the earliest, it's operating on sub-GHz. There has been the addition of some things like Bluetooth Low Energy into newer ones, but still sub-GHz has been the dominant RF architecture for those garage door openers for as long as they've really been available. There's a huge base of installers for managed systems today, whether it's Ring or alarm.com, and most of these managed systems use Z-Wave. And the reason for that is they want to be able to send a kit to a user, have them take that kit out of the box, and whether it's a door sensor or window sensor, or their hub, just put it wherever they want it and not have to worry about the RF performance in the home. And Z-Wave is really proven from an RF performance standpoint and from a configuration standpoint. As she's mentioned, Matt is on helping in Q&A, and before the session we were talking. He just bought a system from Ring, and he pulled everything out of the box, pulled the battery tabs out, and everything just started communicating, working because of the functionality built into Z-Wave. And for a lot of homeowners and a lot of adopters of IoT, they want something like that. They don't want to have to worry about, do I have the right Matter hub? Am I buying the right devices? So with this kit, I can take it out of the box and it just works. Sub-GHz still dominates the low-power space. While standards like Wi-Fi and Matter are making a push into low power, they still aren't optimized as much as the Z-Wave off-the-shelf sub-GHz, or even Zigbee. So, when you talk about the battery life of Matter devices, we're talking in months, where when you look at Z-Wave devices, you're talking an order of magnitude higher when you're talking about years of battery life. That doesn't mean Wi-Fi and Matter won't get there, but today, if you need a low-power device that you need 10 years of life on a coin cell, the Z-Wave and sub-GHz is really where you need to start looking. And lastly, we're seeing a huge amount of adoption of IoT into multi-family residential. When you look at how today's consumer and how today's tenant is changing, they want to have these IoT devices as part of their experience. And, if you rely on tenants to bring their own IoT devices, you run into challenges with safety if they want to wire switches in and do some things like that. If you use a non-managed approach in these instances, you then have to worry about what happens if the homeowner takes it or the tenant takes their Wi-Fi network away. So now the next tenant comes in, and they can't access any of the IoT devices, or you have to send somebody in to reset them all. So what's happening is these multi-family residential property owners are now looking at adding a managed service where they can deploy a bunch of sub-GHz devices in the home, or in their buildings and create that managed, curated experience. And we're seeing a huge amount of growth in that, and a lot of folks are trying to juggle the decision between Matter and Wi-Fi or Zigbee. And it's really, in these instances, sub-GHz has a really strong foothold in the space. Now, going to smart cities. Smart cities are expanding the sub-gig footprints around us, and it's actually starting to expand really quickly when you consider the market. So we're seeing a major uptick in deployments of connected devices for infrastructure, energy management, environmental monitoring. And the easy solution when this first came out was, well, we'll just put cellular in them, and we know the network's there. We can connect, we can pay for the service. But we're seeing some real scalability challenges. You look at a market like India, where you're talking about hundreds of thousands or a million meters in a single deployment. And when you start thinking about the amount of cellular connections and the cost associated with those cellular connections, you hit a real scalability problem. We're seeing a move from proprietary to standards-based solutions. And with this, we've seen a major improvement in network access and reliability. Networks are no longer limited to a single device type or vendor, and they can do this without really compromising performance. There's a growing need for real-time control and monitoring. When you look at some of the intelligence that's being added to streetlights, or you look at what some initiatives that are happening in the cities around us, you need to be able to make decisions at a node level or neighborhood level when they've historically been made at a bigger citywide level. Now, I pulled smart meters out here because I think there are some really interesting facts that show scalability in this space and what's happening in the market today. So with Wi-SUN, there are currently 96.5 million devices deployed in the world that are using Wi-SUN today. When I started this role a couple of years ago, I really didn't understand Wi-SUN and really didn't understand the scope and scale of it. But when you think about almost 100 million devices deployed in the field around us today that are taking advantage of this standard, and you can see how this is changing the smart cities space. When you look at Japan, they're going to have 66 million connected electric meters deployed based on Wi-SUN in the coming future. And here in the US, where Landis+Gyr just announced a deployment in New England that's going to be more than 500,000 meters. And this is really one of the first cases where we're seeing them use this metering network to expand into other use cases. So they're working with gas meters and other sensors to hang off of this network that's being stood up by these line power devices. And you're now removing the burden of network operation from the gas meters to continue that same 10-plus year battery life and that same experience while adding intelligence to those safety-critical meters. When you look at Wirepas in India, they have a million and a half smart meters deployed as of 2024, with projected to four to six million really by the end of 2024, early 2025. And India has the goal to deploy 250 million smart meters here in the near future. So you look at how quickly this is scaling, and Wirepas is a proprietary solution. It's not an open source, or it's not a standards-based solution like Wi-SUN, but we're still seeing huge amounts of deployments and really proving out the functionality of sub-gig in that space when you look at it compared to something like cellular. Now, 2.4 gig definitely still has a place in these network. There are some challenges with distance between nodes and presence of buildings that really limit the feasibility of it for backhaul connection. But we're seeing a need for diagnostics or local sensor network or configuration with a smartphone, or to take advantage of off-the-shelf solutions that really allows these two network topologies to exist at the same time. I touched on this earlier, but we are seeing a growing need for interoperability. I think the days of deployments of smart meters that are only connected to each other and streetlights that are only connected to each other, I think those days are over. Municipalities and utilities that are deploying this equipment are now looking for ways to capture their ROI quicker. And one of the easiest ways to do this is expanding those use cases to allow other devices on these formerly private networks. And that's what we're seeing in that New England use case where Landis+Gyr worked with a utility and a company called National Grid to really create this ecosystem where we're going to spend the money to deploy this Wi-Fi network. Now let's look at how we can get other devices on that network and add more intelligence. Multi-vendor interoperability is critical to the growth in this space. We need to have networks that are acceptable and reliable. And that's now being added at an FLA level to guarantee 90 or 95% uptime. And it's really changing how you have to look at the structure of these networks that are being deployed. And when you look at the performance of sub-gig in the smart city, it's really the only solution that's scalable to the level that we need when we start talking about hundreds of thousands or millions of devices in a single deployment. Now, as Ashish mentioned, I've been in the industry for about 16 years now. The first portion of my career was in sales, and a majority of my customers at that time were industrial control or industrial control adjacent. And as wireless started coming out and taking a bigger foothold, the question was always, "But when are you going to add it?" And there were two challenges with that. The 2.4 gig spectrum was already crowded. So when you look at safety-critical implementations where you need to ensure that signals are being sent and acknowledged, it created some challenge for 2.4 gig, but historically, sub-gig couldn't address the data rates of CAN and RS-232 and RS-485 that are so prevalent in this space. Well, with the adoption of OFDM, we're now getting to a point where we can meet or exceed the performance of those wired interfaces. And this is going to have a huge impact on the industrial space, the warehousing space, because now you're no longer tied to where you have all of these wires already run. You can now optimize your space based on the processes that you're trying to perform. You can dramatically lower cost by not having to run communication lines between equipment. And this really has a huge, or can have a huge impact in the space. Now, 2.4 gig, this is another space where 2.4 gig is still going to have a play. In these instances, you're not going to want or need a cellular connection to get the data out. So you're going to want to be able to interface with the existing IT infrastructure. So whether that's a gateway that's taking sub-gig and then is connected to the existing IT infrastructure or another setup, you can dramatically lower the network overhead cost. If you look at things like I mentioned with the smart city applications where you still want to have people be able to interact with this equipment with a smartphone for diagnostic purposes, 2.4 gig is still going to have a pretty big impact in that space. But really that backhaul communication done with sub-gig is what's changing the face of the market today. So with that, I'm going to bring Ashish back, and we're going to look at some of the questions that we've gotten. So Ashish, what do we got? Yeah. Thanks, Sean. So you talked about smart home and the ring lighting. There's a question on that. With the emergence of standards like Matter making a huge impact on smart home, why would someone look at sub-gig when it requires a bridge device? Yeah, I think when you look at extending the IoT outside of the home, you're going to need some kind of range extender, whether it's a 2.4 gig range extender or whether it's switching that physical protocol to sub-gig. You're going to need something to bridge those applications because 2.4 gig has a problem going through walls, and 5 gig has an even bigger problem going through walls. So you're going to have to have a bridge one way or another. So if you're going to have to do that, why not do it in a way that's optimized for the application that you're trying to solve? Makes sense. There's a question on the chat about modules. Yeah. So, the question is: Is there or will there be in future in Silicon Labs portfolio sub-gig modules? I think we have a FGM230 module. I think this question might be more geared towards future. Yeah. And I think we do have the FGM230S module, but that is not a certified module. It includes all the RF match and everything that you need for those 868 and 915 applications and regions. But there is inherently a certification problem with sub-gig. When you look at certifying at a protocol level or a stack level, there's so much flexibility that's given to the developer that going through the certification for every modulation, every data rate, every frequency, it becomes a prohibitive challenge. That's why we do have modules for Z-Wave. We have Z-Wave certified modules that have the FTC certification and everything that goes along with it because we only have to support Z-Wave. When you look at those other applications outside of that very strict Z-Wave protocol, it becomes a much bigger challenge. I know we have partners who are currently in the process of building modules with our silicon that they will then sell as certified. So I think when you look at it from that standpoint, I don't think it's something we are going to do as a company at this point, but we do have partners that we're working with to provide those solutions for those that need modules. Right. There's a lot of permutation and combination with sub-gig certification. Yeah. There's one more question. What is driving the shift from proprietary to more standard-based networks? It's really the need for innovation. When you take a step back and look at how things like smart meters and streetlights have operated in the past, it's really been limited to, I'm going to use Landis+Gyr as an example. They've deployed smart meters forever, but they've only ever talked to other smart meters. And as we look at how do we scale IoT and smart city, they're looking for ways to drive innovation and drive use cases outside of just theirs. Cisco announced their open DSMP protocol, which is a shim layer that they've historically had that as proprietary and closed to them. And at Distributech earlier this year, they announced they're taking that open source to drive innovation, and that's something that sits on top of Wi-SUN or on top of a protocol and interfaces with their device management. So it's not just the drive from proprietary to standards, but it's also a drive in innovation at that level, where if this is going to scale in a meaningful way, we can't keep that closed ecosystem approach forever. Yeah. So those are all the questions we have so far. I think we can move to the next section. Okay, perfect. So the second half of today's tech talk is really going to focus on the application side of things. And putting this content together is always tricky because if I'm going to talk about asset tracking next, and if you don't have an asset tracking application, how is this relevant to you? But what we've tried to do for this session is look at what's driving the need for connectivity and how to address it with sub-gig, and even how to address it with 2.4 gig at a level that, yeah, I'm using asset tracking as the example, but it's very relevant to other applications as well. So we're going to start with asset tracking. Really, we're seeing a growth in the need to track individual assets throughout the entire supply chain. There are challenges today due to cost of hardware and services to track throughout the entire journey. This is a good example of where the easy answer is cellular. However, when you look at the cost associated with the hardware and the service of maintaining hundreds, thousands of cellular connections, it starts to scale and be cost-prohibitive at scale. So what's happening is it's only the high-dollar, high-value items that are being tracked in the supply chain. And as we all know, that doesn't always solve our problems. There is a high node count challenge here. We may have many hundreds to many thousands of connected nodes present in a small area. That creates some challenges for all networks. Sub-gig is a really good fit for applications like this because you need very good penetration of RF through materials. When you look at pallets that may be in containers or shelves or around other metal objects, you have to be able to get the RF out, and that's really where sub-gig has a good story. Most of these sensors don't need to transmit frequently or at high data rate. So you can really optimize this network for low power with sub-gig and take advantage of where it's good, and shrink that power footprint as low as possible to get as much battery life as you possibly can. And then from the interference standpoint, I think sub-gig has a much better interference story than 2.4 gig. I covered this earlier. But 2.4 gig does still have a place here. There's a need to transmit data more frequently or at different parts of the journey with higher data rates. 2.4 gig standards like Bluetooth have some of those advertising intervals and check-in already built in to enable that. Standardization is another big selling point for 2.4 gig in the space. There are many systems that have to interoperate in these setups, and if they're all using a standard protocol that's built on 2.4 gig, it makes the entire system much easier to manage. And worldwide support, I covered this in my first slide. 2.4 gig is a worldwide supported frequency, so as you look at devices that may have to travel outside of regions and around the world, you start running into those challenges with sub-gig. But sub-gig definitely has advantages, but there's no one perfect solution for this application. Shifting gears to something a little more relatable to all of us, parking availability tracking. This is something that I saw in action firsthand on a trip to, my wife and I went to Disney Springs a year or so ago. And as you drive through their parking garages, you can look down and see every parking spot has a red or green light to let you know if it's occupied or open. And that saves a lot of time, it saves a lot of fuel, and it dramatically lowers the environmental impact. If I don't have to spend 15 minutes, 20 minutes driving through a parking garage looking for a spot, I can just easily look down the row and see is there a green light and is it available. In general, that's the goal. You want to monitor and notify drivers, lights or something more simple like that. But there are very different requirements, whether we're talking about an open air- Major advantage with, they can travel longer distances, they can penetrate through walls. The low power performance is definitely- Josh. Yep. Sorry, your video froze for a couple of seconds there. Maybe if we can talk about the last piece again. Yeah, absolutely. So again, with parking, it really depends on if you're looking at those urban environments or smaller footprint closed environments like parking garages, as to what you need to optimize this network for. The urban canyon performance of sub-GHz is a huge advantage. And also, these sensors don't need to typically transmit very frequently. You get a state change notification where, am I occupied or not? So, you can really optimize the performance of those sensors with sub-GHz. And then, looking at the city implementations, this is a place where you can really take advantage of Wi-SUN and its mesh networking capability where you can deploy these sensors and add them to a network that's already deployed with streetlights or smart meters or something line powered and really optimize them for what they're doing and not make them carry the burden of the network infrastructure piece. Now, 2.4 GHz, it's perfect for that garage implementation that I was talking about earlier, where you're just looking at keeping the sensing contained to a single floor of a parking garage, or even a single building, because you can take advantage of the mesh network capabilities of these 2.4 GHz networks, and you don't have to worry about that point-to-point range. And mesh networks like Zigbee, like Thread, they're very scalable as well, so you can easily add as many sensors as you need to cover your entire area without having a big impact. Irrigation monitoring control is one that has an impact both in the home and in agriculture. There are a wide variety of needs depending on your use cases. Typically, the goal of these systems is to understand and control resource utilization. And the example that I like to use, most sprinkler systems today, at least for the home, are controlled by a single controller. It may or may not be connected, so you're either just setting a time that you want it to work, or it may be pulling the weather, and optimizing for that. But you have no way of knowing do your plants actually need water? And the easiest way to do that is by putting sensors around these areas and whether it's with D-Wave Long Range for the home or Wi-SUN or ProGris Erry for the more agriculture side of things. These are sensors that you're going to put in the ground and then forget about until the battery dies, and then you may go and replace it. So you need that long battery life. You need the long range, because you need to reduce the number of gateways required to cover a large amount of land in an agriculture standpoint or get outside the home in a home use case. Again, these are low-bandwidth sensors that really don't have to transmit data very frequently, which is right in that sweet spot of where sub-GHz plays. Now, for indoor applications like greenhouses and things like that, you don't need the range. That's a great spot for a 2.4 GHz mesh and can really take advantage of the benefits of IPV6 addressability of things like Matter and Thread and really shine in those kind of closed greenhouse use cases. Building and security automation, this is a place where Z-Wave and sub-GHz have always had a pretty good foothold, and I think that's just expanding as we look at how these use cases are affecting the world around us. You need robust connectivity. You can't worry about nodes dropping off the network, and then now people can't get into their office or get into their area. You need to cover a large number of assets, so congestion and scalability are important. And you need to be able to support both line-powered and battery-powered end nodes. I used to have a customer in the security space who tried to do this with Bluetooth and does do this with Bluetooth, but they really need a gateway to support every 10 deployed devices. And when you look at that and look at the amount of gateways that would require to support an office building, that becomes cost-prohibitive from an infrastructure standpoint. Now, 2.4 GHz, I mentioned IPV6 addressability earlier. Having that addressability is important to these systems because they're typically managed by IT, for credentials, for access control, and support are typically done by IT or security. So having that native translation from their network to this IoT network is a big advantage. And obviously, the mesh capability of some of these 2.4 GHz standards is a big advantage here, too. I have two more application slides, then we've got another Q&A. So if you have questions, get them in. Solar trackers are an emerging market. This is something as we look to expand the distributed energy resources in the world around us. It starts with solar and wind and some of those, and these are typically large-scale implementations where they have large geographic footprints, a very diverse landscape, and they present a pretty unique RF challenge when you look at all of the metal and the materials used in the panels themselves. They have very high node count and multiple types of nodes. So you may have a different node that controls the movement of the solar panel, then controls the communication to the central management system. And this is actually a space where we're seeing a pretty big push from standards like Matter, who are looking to consolidate these energy resources at a residential level. So it's an infrastructure play, and it is also a residential piece, and it creates challenges in both instances. So when you look at how sub-GHz can make an impact, the network scalability and maintenance are key here. So when you look at some of these self-forming, self-healing networks like Wi-SUN and Wirepas, it really makes the scalability and the maintenance of these networks easier. I mentioned the emergence of Matter. Zigbee has always had a big foothold in this space. And I think this is another use case where having that local 2.4 GHz connection has a big impact on that maintenance experience. So allowing technicians to interface through a smartphone or a tablet to determine what's going on with the system is a big deal. And then the last one that I'm going to talk about is HVAC. We're seeing a huge push from HVAC companies to get rid of whether it's the standard communication interface that they have or communicating systems for the 48 volt AC that's typically more common. And the reason for that is the wiring increases cost and complexity. It creates an installation challenge. These systems are typically installed in very RF-challenging environments where you need an outdoor unit that's obviously sitting outside that needs to communicate with a furnace that's down in the basement somewhere and a thermostat that's somewhere on another level or in another part of the home. So it creates some unique RF challenges. We're seeing a lot of interest in that OFDM modulation and the data rates that it brings for the high throughput in these applications, because you can replace these wired connections. And energy efficiency is always a key care about, so it can monitor and you can meet the energy requirements of these systems. Now, for 2.4 GHz, I think we're looking at two different things here. One is the HVAC equipment itself, which is a perfect fit for sub-GHz. On the interface and thermostat side of things, that's where homeowners really care about the ecosystem support, and everything that goes along with it. Now, I will say I have an Ecobee system in my house, and it's obviously connected with Wi-Fi and Bluetooth and communicates with my phone and does all that, but their sensors are still sub-GHz. So they're still taking advantage of the object penetration and everything that they get with sub-GHz for their sensors that they don't have control over where those are placed in the home. So with that, I'm actually going to skip over the last one and we're going to go to a Q&A. So Ashish, what do we got? We have multiple questions, but Jake and Matt has been answering most of them. There are some open questions, though. One is why no mention of LoRa? I think you did mention it in the beginning. Yeah. I mentioned LoRa at the beginning, as one of those emerging standards, and I think, for this, I did try to focus on the applications that we have support for. I also think when you look at the scalability of LoRa in the market, it does create some challenges. They don't support OTA with standards like Wi-SUN and Wirepas and even Amazon Sidewalk support today. So, when you look at how these networks evolve to the changing landscape of IoT, I think that is somewhat limited. And again, the main reason is because we don't have support for it. LoRa is proprietary to Semtech and their CSS modulation scheme. So it does lock you into a modulation, and locks you into a support structure. The other question is on the security. I don't know if there's one single answer for it. It says which sub-GHz method is the most secure, I guess, which protocol. Yeah, I think it really depends on what you're looking at and how you're defining security. When you look at Z-Wave, Z-Wave has their own security implementation and has implemented smart start, where you scan a QR code on the device, all of those device parameters are then passed to the network and are set up that way. So you have that very secure setup piece. When you look at Wi-SUN, they take advantage of certificate-based authenticity or authentication like you have in a normal IT network. So they're addressing it that way. Wirepas has their own security scheme, and Sidewalk uses a very robust, public-private encryption pair scheme where the data is encrypted from the time it leaves the device to the time it's decrypted at the server level. So it's really not an easy question to answer from what is most secure. It really depends on what you define is most secure and what approach works best for you- Got it ... in that big picture. Yeah, and since you mentioned the Sidewalk, does Amazon Sidewalk support OTA? Amazon Sidewalk in general supports OTA. I see this is a question about sub-GHz OTA, and Matt can respond in the chat if I'm wrong, but I believe they do support sub-GHz OTA. I don't believe it's supported over LoRa or over the CSS modulation that they use. But I see Jake is typing an answer, so hopefully I didn't mess it up too much. And the final question, it's a more generic question. How does Silicon Lab simplify the sub-GHz or 2.4 GHz disadvantages or problems that you covered? Yeah. Yeah, and I think that's a good question to end on for today. I think when you look at how we have approached the needs of an IT developer, our entire EFR Series 2 portfolio is firmware compatible. So if you have a product line that you want to support sub-GHz and you want to support Matter or you want to support Bluetooth, you can do that with a single application firmware set. So we have our rail abstraction layer that sits on top of the radio that really simplifies that radio interaction, and you can really almost treat the radio like a peripheral and focus on the development of your application for the EFR32 platform, and then let that radio piece change underneath it as the needs of your application change. It's a common tool set, it's a common AI/ML and security subsystem. So if you're taking advantage of AI/ML acceleration at the edge for faster inferencing, you don't have to change that from device to device. And the security is the same as well. So we have a dedicated security core and dedicated security subsystem. And that's the same from any of our Series 2 platform, whether it's on secure vault mid or secure vault high. And we do offer devices in similar packages or in the same packages, so we do have that package compatibility as well. You should pay attention to pinouts and everything on that design because not everything is pin compatible, but it is package compatible. So Chad, that was the last question. Okay. And I know this is the last session this year for LPWAN. Yep. You want to take it home? Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, so like Ashish just mentioned, this is the last session for LPWAN for our first half tech talk series. So I appreciate everybody who's been a part of this, from the opening one. I think we do still have four more tech talk sessions in other tracks next week with Matter where Matt and Rob Alexander are going to talk about some emerging things in Matter. Stay tuned for Works With in the fall. We're working on getting that put together for you all, and hopefully news on that will be coming out soon, but appreciate you coming and attending and hopefully see you in the next couple weeks for Matter, Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and wireless compute. So with that, thanks everybody, and enjoy the rest of your day. Thanks, Chad. Thanks, everyone.    

Close
Loading Results
Close